This was a response to a comment thread by KD, on the post about my view on the childlessness problem everyone is apparently so worried about in the West.
I felt it was useful enough to reproduce the thread as a full post.
After reading my post and why I am not particularly worried, and what I mean by City States being part of the solution that I think will naturally occur, KD said:
The programming of the West is a beast that has been eating from the toes up. It’s tragic to be unplugged from it while watching the pure evil destruction unleashed on people everyday. There’s a good chunk of women that don’t know how to get there. They had no father’s and were most likely abused by a male relative or teachers growing up. Zero protection and zero guidance. The only ones around were the perverts taking advantage of damaged girls. Grooming them to become porn addicted sluts. Encouraging guys to become pump and dump guys. To further degrade an already destroyed psyche. That’s why destroying strong men was the first order. To remove the balls necessary for guidance and protection of their children. Then sterilizing women and putting them to work. Then women get used to transactional living so when it comes to marital values there is no perceived payoff thereby giving themselves free reign to be the sluts their programming is attempting to make them. They break vows to be with tony soprano or duke the sky diving dude because their programming makes it a transaction. Women aren’t supposed to operate this way. Their true role is so important that it’s the most corrupted and the least guided. Steadfast religious belief, specifically Sedevacantist, is the only way to provide the protective even harsh guidance for women. Because in their emotional eyes anything they don’t want or like will be a harsh. It’s already known we women have a particular problem with solipsistic habits. The current state of the world is what happens when women accept transactional living over spiritual living.
I replied:
Indeed. The difference is that in my experience, the Catholic women are pretty much choosing the “harsh” themselves and doing so in a very happy and conscious fashion. That’s the difference between true faith/belief, and a pretend version.
She responded:
I see what you mean by that difference. It explains the Churchians quite a bit.
And I thought it was a good opportunity to expand on the topic in a way I haven’t really done before:
I was baptised on ascension day 2017 and have now lived in Italy since 2021 in what used to be a very Catholic country until the usurpation of the Church by Satanists began to erode those values from 1958, but that remains part of the underlying cultural fabric still to this day in many respects. Even then it took me at least a year here and more like two, to be able to begin to see how deeply Protestantism has affected humanity, and always in a net negative way. A further mechanising and dehumanising of people. Catholicism places the human being in a central even if subjugate position. It is why the analogy with God being the Father is so apt. Your child, as a loving father, should obey you, not to satisfy your ego (as the gnostics try to imply, and the Satanists do for their master) but because your rules are there to protect, guide, and help him enjoy life the most.
The fact an Italian work force may be late because they stopped to have coffee on the way in is irritating to an anglo marinaded in protestant “efficiency”, but the same protestant efficiency will put you in jail for breaking some minor human law of no consequence. And the Italian workmen may stay on to work until midnight at no extra charge because they see you have small children and need the job done fast. Under Protestantism, the humanity is first diluted then lost, and all under the guise of “freedom” and “equality” and “diversity” and “fairness” in the Protestant zeitgeist.
Even Italians secularised for almost a century now still have a better grasp of the sexual dynamics between men and women and the raising of a family than anything I have ever observed in any of the Anglosphere countries, nor the Teutonic ones. The closest to it are the Russians and it’s a distant second at best with respect to raising a family, although at least in part, their women have learnt to be more objective than western women (with a 50-50 split of when that is a good thing and when it exposes them as monsters with little conscience that women can be in quite different ways from men). And keep in mind they have Eastern schismatic Christianity, which, erroneous as it is, is still light-years closer to the truth than the most pious of Protestant heresies.
It takes a while living as a Catholic even in a nominally Catholic country, to see the massive advantages of Catholicism over Protestantism, especially if, like myself, you tend to be focused on results instead of methods, efficiency instead of comfort, and so on. As a scout, I am used to discomfort, pushing through, and not giving up even against massive odds against me, but of course all of that brutalises you too, and makes you see those who will not, or cannot, as weak, cowardly, lazy, or a combination of all of those (rightly so mainly). But in taking time to perceive the subtleties and depth of Catholicism, you then become aware of the possibility of becoming less brutal, both towards others (easier) as well as yourself (less easy), while not only losing nothing or perhaps only very little in terms of “efficiency”, but gaining massively in both peace of mind as well as long-term positive results down the line. It is more likely for a Protestant mindset to “win” the battle and completely lose the war. For example by pushing through in his career and ending up in divorce court. While a Catholic is far more likely to win the war (with some much needed footnotes) by say not becoming a millionaire but having a happy and numerous family (the two things are not mutually exclusive by the way, the example is designed to make the average Protestant pause and reflect on the relative values he sees in each side of the example).
The footnotes are mostly that this is also a LOT easier to do this if you are surrounded by Catholics too, and harder to see (and by default lead) if you are the pioneer in your area. But the benefit is that a proper Catholic community can achieve results no other group of humans has achieved in human history. Just look at all the Catholic cathedrals and artwork littered around ex-Catholic countries. And if that level of faith and community were turned towards the stars, the fictional book The High Crusade may well happen at a speed and efficiency no one even suspects of being plausible, never mind possible.
This post was originally published on my Substack. Link here
